rent, and had the advantage of much free labor of apprentices. This
produced another investigating committee and a long report, which
attempted - none too successfully - to answer Mr. Lincoln's
questions. The single change made by the trustees was to limit the
value of oral contracts to be made by the superintendent to
$1,000. Contracts above this amount were to be approved by the shop
committee. In 1891 Charles H. Morgan gave a vigorous report for the
committee, affirming that they saw no need for changing methods, nor
had they any scheme to propose for future management. "All we seem to
need is stronger faith in our past, well-tested policy, and more
enthusiasm for the future."
The following year Charles G. Washburn, junior member of the shop
committee, made a real engineering report on shop transactions. He
showed that with proper accounting for instruction costs, the shops
were making a profit of 15 per cent on total sales. Elevator sales
netted 8 per cent, grinders, about 7 per cent, and drill grinders,
40.5 per cent. This report had additional merit in the eyes of the
historian, for it was the first Institute document written on a
typewriter.
The faculty also took occasion to raise a question about the
shops. "Are we one educational institution with several branches
having similar relations to a common trunk, or are we two institutions
- the Institute and the Shops - placed side by side for mutual
convenience?" judge Aldrich, Senator Hoar, and Mr. Morgan answered the
question emphatically in a report of great length. "The Institute is
one institution under the government of one managing board of
trustees, having full power, from time to time, to prescribe such
rules and regulations, in each and every department of the Institute,
including the shop, as they may deem best to promote the highest
welfare of the whole institution." That was in 1891, and it settled
the question for nearly a decade.
The success of the Washburn Shops in building and selling plunger
elevators brought a competitor, the Worcester Elevator Co., into the
field. As early as 1887, this company
|